Mi Pueblo DBQ available for download!

See below for a great resource from two OUSD teachers for teaching about the 1-9 audit at Mi Pueblo.

—-

Please share with other educators! Check-out the lesson materials here!

Dear teacher colleagues in OUSD and other Bay Area schools,

Many of you have probably heard about the impending 1-9 audit of Mi Pueblo stores (more info below) that poses a serious threat to the economic livelihood and stability of many of students’ families throughout the Bay Area. Both of us work at Oakland schools and have several students whose family members are employed by Mi Pueblo and many more students who know someone who works there. In the broader climate of both attacks on immigrant communities and economic hardship for OUSD families in Oakland, we felt compelled to do what we can as teachers to support our school communities. We are writing to share what we hope is a useful lesson plan and set of resources for teaching your students about the situation at Mi Pueblo and opening up dialogue in your classroom about immigrant and worker rights issues.

Click here to view the Mi Pueblo Document Based Question Lesson Plan and resources page. From there you can easily download the lesson materials including a detailed lesson plan, student readings and worksheets, powerpoints and primary documents. The lesson is designed to support students to write an evidence-supported paragraph in response to the question: To what extent should Mi Pueblo or the Federal Government be held responsible if immigrant workers lose their jobs because of the I-9 immigration audit? There is an optional action-based extension suggested as well.

Taught in its entirety, the lesson will take several class periods, however it could easily be shortened into a 1 or 2 day lesson. It could be adapted for a middle or high school classroom. It is great practice in preparation for the OUSD fall DBQ history assessment or for learning document sourcing and analysis and argumentative writing skills in general. This would fit in perfectly to a unit about immigration, industrialization, labor, civil rights or federal juridiction. The materials are all editable so you can adapt to the student needs and current foci of your classroom.

Please consider carving out time this December or January to teach about this struggle. Please also pass along to any other teachers you might know who might be interested. And if you do implement part of the lesson in your class, let us know! We would love to see what your students come up with and let Mi Pueblo workers know young people are investigating the situation.

Be in touch if you have any questions about the materials. And please note, this is a work in progress! If you add any lesson materials in ways you think would be helpful for others or create any new materials, please share with us so we can upload to share it with others.

Thank you for engaging your students in critically analyzing the world around them,

Perry Bellow-Handelman, perrybh@gmail.com

Alexander Mejia, alexmejia@gmail.com

Summary and Update about the Mi Pueblo 1-9 Audit

In early fall, the Mi Pueblo grocery store chain, which employs over 3,000 mainly immigrant workers in the Bay Area, began implementing Immigration and Custom Enforcement’s E-verify system under which the social security numbers of all new job applicants are checked. A short while later Mi Pueblo announced that they had voluntarily joined E-verify because they are undergoing I-9 immigration audit through which all undocumented workers at their stores are expected to lose their jobs. Layoffs are expected to start on January 1, 2013. Whether Mi Pueblo was forced to undergo the 1-9 audit by ICE or volunteered to do so is unknown. However Mi Pueblo has been putting out a consistent message to their primary Latino immigrant cliental that their commitment to immigrant rights is unwavering and that they are doing everything they can to support immigrant workers at the store.

This all came on the backdrop of a several year long effort by UFCW to unionize workers at the non-union stores and a hunger strike held by workers at one of the stores in 2011 in protest of working conditions, low wages and firings of pro-union workers. Several community groups see the audit has an attempt by management to squash union organizing efforts and other worker dissent. They have joined together under the name of “Dignity and Resistance Coalition” and are organizing to demand Mi Pueblo not collaborate with ICE and not move forward with the 1-9 audit firings.

On October 20th and November 21^st (the day before Thanksgiving-often a busy day for grocery stores) there were very energetic pickets held outside of the Mi Pueblo on High St. in Oakland. At each of these protests there were over a hundred people in attendance who marched, chanted, gave out information and watched various showings of a community theatre performance based on the struggle of Mi Pueblo workers. The Dignity and Resistance Coalition has continued to organize around the situation of the workers and build community support. In other areas of the bay, the UFCW is continuing to have meetings with workers in order to unionize.

While the I-9 audit is still taking place but no (or very few) workers have been fired yet. Some say that the slow pace of how the audit is being implemented is due to the negative press and community resistance that Mi Pueblo is receiving. Others say that Mi Pueblo is waiting until after the holidays (their busiest time of year) to fire these workers so as not to diminish their revenue at this important time for them financially.

The United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW), a union that is in the middle of an organizing drive with the Mi Pueblo workers is putting together two upcoming actions in San Jose: the first one will be a community forum about workers rights and organizing on December 9^th and a protest in against sexual harassment at Mi Pueblo on December 18^th. There will be other upcoming actions around the Christmas holiday that are organized by the Dignity and Resistance Coalition. For more information about their current organizing, you can contact bertaofelia@hotmail.com.

About these ads

Comments 2 Comments
Categories Curriculum & Teaching Resources

2 Responses to “Mi Pueblo DBQ available for download!”

TEACH December 14, 2012 at 5:17 am #

Below is an email we received in response to the lesson plan from a veteran teacher and teacher educator who we deeply respect. We found her points very useful so sharing it here for others who are teaching the lesson:

Hi;

what a great idea! And well done. Below are a few hurried thoughts. I didn’t read the plans in detail so my thoughts are based upon what I take to be your focal question.

When you extend it I think it needs a “pre-quel.”

The focus of your unit is
“To what extent should Mi Pueblo or the Federal Government be held responsible if immigrant workers lose their jobs because of the I-9 immigration audit?”

I think there are a variety of ways to frame the fundamental issues in preparation for focusing on your major focus question (though I also suggest you consider refocusing that question).

I’m wondering if students should first explore the question of whether immigrants should have the right to work if they are undocumented. I think students are much more likely to care about your question if they are clear and fired up about immigrant rights, and many may not have a good understanding of the two or various points of view about this.

Then perhaps you might focus on your question not by asking an abstract question about who is responsible or what is responsible, but to ask students what they want to do about the Mi Pueblo situation. This will bring your question into focus in a clear fashion and will raise the question in a way that may be much more likely to capture the kids interest. I’d like to talk with you about what your mean by responsible–who caused it/ who is responsible for solving it?

Hope this is helpful.

Reply